Wednesday, June 16, 2010

New Chair and Vice chair elected

At tonight's meeting Henry Brackett was elected chair 4-2 with Jennifer and Joann against.

Jocelyn O'Quinn was elected vice chair unanimously.

Mark Townsend/Attorney Email String

The school board has granted the release of these emails.  As promised in an earlier post, they are at the link below.

Thanks!

Mark Townsend Email String

Reminder: Follow Oyster River Community on Facebook!

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

School Board Special Meeting June 15, 2010 SAU Conference Room

REVISED Time Change

AGENDA Oyster River Cooperative School District


School Board Special Meeting June 15, 2010 SAU Conference Room


I Non-Meeting Consultation with Legal Counsel under RSA 91-A:2 I (c)


II Call to Order


III Action Item


IV. Adjournment


The School Board reserves the right to take action on any item on the agenda.

Respectfully submitted, Howard Colter, Superintendent

SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER VACANCY

NOTICE Oyster River Cooperative School District SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER VACANCY June 10, 2010

The Oyster River Cooperative School District School Board is seeking a citizen from Madbury to fill the vacancy on the School Board until the next election on March 8, 2011.


Citizens are encouraged to submit a brief letter of interest and summary of qualifications to the School Board no later than Thursday, June 24, 2010. Letters may be sent via email to wdifruscio@orcsd.org or delivered to SAU #5, 36 Coe Drive, Durham, NH 03824, Attn: Wendy DiFruscio. Our office is open from 7:30 am to 4:00 pm daily.


The School Board will review letters of interest and hold brief interviews at a special School Board meeting on Wednesday, June 30, 2010 @ 7:00 pm and select one citizen to fill the vacancy.


Citizens that submit a letter of interest will receive an invitation to meet the Board on the evening of June 30, 2010.

If you have any questions, please contact Wendy DiFruscio at 868-5100, ext 20, or email at wdifruscio@orcsd.org.

Sunday, June 13, 2010

Suggestion to Superintendent Colter to Improve Communication

On Friday, June 11, 2010, I sent a letter to Superintendent Colter and copied the School Board suggesting the Superintendent issue a monthly letter to the Oyster River community (see full text of letter below).

That same day I was happy to hear back from Mr. Colter who offered to meet to discuss my suggestion. I view this as positive step towards increased District communication.

***

Dear Mr. Colter:


In my own effort to see how our District can improve communication, I searched through available correspondence on the ORCSD web site. The most recent correspondence I found was a January 2010 Board Newsletter addressing, primarily, the upcoming warrant articles and the 2010 Report of the District (containing mostly statistics/data). Besides these documents, I found no letters from your office to the greater Oyster River community.


I have a suggestion, and forgive my boldness. Would you please start issuing a monthly letter via the ORCSD web site and to subscribers on a specific listserv to the Oyster River Community? The monthly letter would address the following:

* Superintendent's thoughts on the educational vision for our District

* Progress on major educational, operational, and other program initiatives

* Profiles on outstanding students from each school

* Special awards/recognition of teachers/staff

* Anything else you think appropriate (e.g., other District activities, major educational policies from the State level, etc.)


I realize that many items in this monthly letter may be redundant with what you report during regular Board meetings. However, I think a monthly newsletter would be extremely helpful, especially to inform the vast majority of community members who do not watch/attend Board meetings.


If you would like, I and other community members could help craft the format of the letter in greater detail. I may be reached via e-mail (XXX@XXXX) or phone (XXX-XXXX) to set up a meeting to pursue this in detail.


At the May 19, 2010 School Board meeting, I mentioned how I wish to see the Board instill policy and practice that will ensure that our District staff is successful. Although I was referring to fiscal practices, I feel this statement applies to your office's communication as well. Our children's education is on the line and we need to strive for more open communication. Thank you for your time.


Thursday, June 10, 2010

OR School Board Has Much to Explain

Op/Ed in Fosters today...Join us on Facebook!

The Oyster River School Board may be within its rights to not release a controversial e-mail chain between former School Board Chair Mark Townsend and attorneys from the district and the New Hampshire School Board Association.

That said, the board should waive attorney-client privilege and release the e-mails in the name of open and transparent governance.

The e-mails had been requested by Foster's Daily Democrat and district residents to shed light on the recent resignation of Townsend and allegations leveled by and against him. These allegations include personal wranglings between Townsend and board member Ann Wright over comments allegedly made about her family.

In addition, Townsend leveled charges of "backroom deals" and a "toxic" board environment when he announced his resignation Monday.

Under the state's Right-to-Know Law, attorney-client communications can be withheld from the public, but don't have to be.

Most often this exclusion is used when boards seek advice concerning personnel problems, labor contracts or land purchases — not nasty internal board matters.

In the case of the Oyster River School Board, the e-mail exchange was brought on by Townsend seeking a legal opinion about "the proper role of the board and individual members with respect to communication with town officials," according to Superintendent Howard Colter.

But while the Right-to-Know Law allows legal correspondence to be withheld, it requires matters concerning board members to be aired in public.

The decision to withhold the e-mails comes down on the wrong side of this fine line.

The public has a right to know what is going on among board members — their elected public officials. In this case, the information is particularly important because of Townsend's allegations the board is essentially dysfunctional. And further, that it is doing business behind closed doors, i.e. backroom deals.

The latter charge, in particular, raises the specter of illegal behavior on the part of board members.

In the long run, refusing to release the e-mails will do more harm than good. It will leave lingering doubt over the veracity of all school board members and their actions.

That serves neither the residents of the Oyster River School District nor its students. 

From Kim Clark - Former Board Chair

I am sure some will roll their eyes that I am making a statement, so if that is the case, commence with the eye roll now.

I am deeply saddened by the recent occurrences on the School Board.  It is very difficult to know just how challenging the task of a Board member is until you actually find yourself sitting in that hot seat every other Wednesday night.  I hope we all continually strive to understand a Board member is constantly trying to balance and prioritize both public and non-public information to make the best decisions they are capable of, and I believe we all need to support those willing to volunteer their time even when we disagree with their positions and opinions.  This doesn’t mean we should stop voicing our interests and concerns given that the Board is intended to be an extension of us, the voters, and they can’t do their job without knowing what we want.

Inexperience is nothing new to this School Board or any Oyster River Cooperative School Board that has come before it.  I hope that we can get over that label and certainly stop using it as an excuse for why things are the way they are.  I personally believe that diversity across the members, critical thinkers and fresh ideas are far more important than experience for a School Board to be effective and progressive, especially today.

In regards to the e-mails, in my experience on the Board we often did seek “legal opinion”.  The Board can meet and vote as to whether or not to release a “legal opinion”.  I would like to know when the Board met, discussed and voted on this issue.  I would like to know what the vote was.  This all should be public record.

If the Board did not meet to discuss the release or non-release of these e-mails, and have not voted, then I am curious as to why Superintendent Colter would make the statement in yesterday’s Foster’s that this had indeed occurred.  This distinction will be important to clarify, in order to prevent the public from making assumptions.

I also am curious about whether the emails in question came from the district attorney or the New Hampshire School Board Association, because there is a big difference between the two.  I would point out that an “opinion” from the New Hampshire School Board Association is different than a “legal opinion” from an attorney.  At the bottom of each e-mail from the NHSBA it specifically states “”The information provided here does not establish an attorney client relationship”, so is not subject to the rules governing attorney client privilege.

Also, at the bottom of each e-mail from the school district it states, “The right to know law provides that most e-mail communications, to or from school district employees regarding the business of the school district, are government records available to the public upon request.” 

I am sure some will say releasing the e-mails will only cause more of a problem. I don’t agree, and in my past Board experience, not being open with the public and not communication effectively with the public is what seems to be the core driver behind many of the Board’s issues.  The assumption of what may be in the e-mails, in my opinion, is worse than what may be in those e-mails.

I also hope the assertion of “back room deals” will stop immediately or be backed up with some kind of evidence.  My sense is there were none, except in the imagination of some.  My evidence is that I called a School Board Representative, and asked, as all citizens have a right to do.  Maybe even more to the point; it is perfectly legal for Board members to discuss issues outside of Board meetings as long as they don’t have a quorum or sequential communication on a specific topic.  As stated from the NH School board association and the training guide “Becoming a better board member.”
  1. Is a board member allowed to discuss agenda items with one other board member outside of a meeting?

1.  Yes, a board member is allowed to discuss agenda items with another board member outside of a meeting.  So long as a quorum is not involved in the actual discussion, the discussion does not constitute a meeting with the definition of “meeting” under RSA 91-A:2.  However, there are a few caveats.
 
RSA 91-A:2-a, II states:  “Communications outside a meeting, including, but not limited to, sequential communications among members of a public body, shall not be used to circumvent the spirit and purpose of this chapter as expressed in RSA 91-A:1.”

Thus, it would be ill-advised and likely contrary to the provisions of the Right to Know law to consult with board member outside of a meeting, then to immediately consult with a second board member about the same topic or item, and then to immediately consult with a third board about the same topic, and so forth.  These would fit within the meaning of “sequential communication” and would likely violate the Right to Know law.
 These accusations not supported with hard facts are dangerous, and this recent situation proves this.

Our newest members of the Board, as well as those who have been serving for some time, all care about making our district greater than it is.  Let us support them in moving ahead, and stop the attacks on board members who give countless hours to their community.

Of most importance, I hope our teachers are able to finish off this school year knowing that most in the community support all that they do and continue to believe we have a great school district.

Thank you,

Kim Clark

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

School Board Chair Needs to Apologize - UPDATE

Here is the response I got today from the SAU on the RSA request for the email trail talked about at the last meeting.  I guess Foster's was told the same thing.

At the present time the School Board is seeking legal counsel, but the preliminary indication is that this is Attorney Client privileged information and therefore of a nonpublic nature.  


Thanks for all the comments.  The visitors on the blog have more than tripled since last week.  I especially appreciate all teachers and staff commenting.  It provides insight on both sides that the public doesn't usually get to hear.  


So, thank you, and a special thanks for being unified on how great the teachers and students are in our district!!!


By the way....we are on Facebook.  Click here 

Oyster River School Board Won't Release Emails

DURHAM — The Oyster River School Board will not release a controversial e-mail chain between former School Board Chair Mark Townsend and attorneys from the district and the New Hampshire School Board Association, according to Superintendent Howard Colter.

Colter said the e-mail exchange was brought on by Townsend seeking a legal opinion about "the proper role of the board and individual members with respect to communication with town officials."

However, there were accusations made at the June 2 School Board meeting, which was public, that Townsend made comments about board member Ann Wright's family and made accusations against the board in the e-mails.

In addition to Foster's, a few district residents have also requested the e-mails, according to Colter. Colter said the board has decided not to release the e-mails at the advice of its attorney.

"It's being treated as privileged correspondence between attorney/client," Colter said.

Townsend resigned from his post on Monday morning. He said the e-mails had nothing to do with his resignation.

Neither Colter nor Townsend would confirm what incident brought on the need for a legal opinion.

Board members do communicate with their respective towns from time to time in order to update them on board business.

More recently, board member Henry Brackett spoke as a private citizen about School Board business to the Lee Board of Selectmen on May 10.

According to meeting minutes, Brackett did express some opinions about how the School Board conducts business, including an exchange about bidding procedures and the way warrant articles are worded.

There was also one exchange with selectmen about transparency on the school board.

"Selectman (Frank) DeRocchi states he would like to work with the other towns to gain transparency. Selectman (James) Griswold asks how we obtain transparency in the School District," according to the meeting minutes. "Mr. Brackett states that it helps that the School Board has recently changed with two members; Krista Butts and Ann Wright, both ask many questions."

Brackett couldn't be reached for comment on Tuesday.

Tonight the School Board will begin the process of choosing a new board chair and addressing the open position on the board, according to Colter.

Colter expressed disappointment over Townsend's resignation on Monday and noted that Townsend was very active on board subcommittees.

"I was sorry to see him step down. I think he was a valuable member of the School Board," he said.

Townsend cited the board not following procedures along with "backroom deals" as reasons for his resignation.

Colter admitted the board has gone through some rough patches this year in regard to following procedure; a fact he said could be attributed to board inexperience.

"I really respect the School Board as a whole," he said. "They're learning their roles as a board and learning each other and I have every confidence they will learn the job and come together as a cohesive team."

Tonight's special meeting of the Oyster River School Board is scheduled for 7:30 p.m. at the Oyster River High School.

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

ORCSD School Board Chair Resigns...again

Oyster River School Board chair resigns citing 'backroom deals' By Aaron Sanborn
asanborn@fosters.com
DURHAM — For the second time in less than a year, the person serving as the chair of the Oyster River School Board has resigned.

Mark Townsend submitted his letter of resignation to the board Monday morning after serving on the board for just over a year

Townsend, of Madbury, didn't elaborate on his reasons for resigning, only saying that the board not following procedures along with "backroom deals" contributed to his decision.

"Participation on this board has always been challenging, and for the better part of my first year the challenge was also rewarding," Townsend said in his letter of resignation. "This year the environment has been increasingly toxic. We moved from a board equally balanced on experience to a very inexperienced board. This has not helped."

Townsend went on to call the board "divided" and questioned whether or not the board is working together as a board of seven or a smaller number.

"Accountability starts at the board," his letter said. "Many ran on the platform of accountability, yet still have not accounted for their inexperience or mistakes."

Townsend was at the center of an uncomfortable moment at the board's last meeting on June 2, where he was accused of writing disparaging e-mails about the board and a board member's family.

He said those e-mails had nothing to do with his resignation but said what happened at that meeting helped to finalize his decision.

According to video from the meeting, Townsend was discussing e-mails between him and the district's attorneys regarding an opinion he was seeking. During that discussion, Board Member Ann Wright expressed concern about a comment Townsend wrote in the e-mail about her family, along with other allegations he made against the board.

"I don't appreciate you mentioning my family in an e-mail to an attorney and disparaging me to an attorney," Wright told Townsend during the meeting. "I found it hurtful. We have a board goal of unity ... and I find it's going to be very very difficult right now to achieve that after reading your e-mails, your accusations in there."

Townsend commented during the meeting that he didn't know which e-mails Wright was referring to.

Townsend declined to discuss the nature of the e-mails with Foster's on Monday, calling them "privileged information."

Wright didn't return a call Monday seeking comment.

Amid growing public concerns about transparency on the board, much of the board's recent discussion have centered around the creation of a budget advisory committee and an audit committee, issues that have divided the board at time.

Townsend briefly acknowledged those two issues in his resignation letter.

"I see focus on two financial pieces, yet for all the focus on money where is the focus on education?" he said. "This board will face many challenges this year, but I sincerely hope that it does not forget its first charge — to ensure the education of our children."

Townsend said he plans on going back to being a regular citizen with "a bad taste in his mouth of public service."

Finding new board members is nothing new to the School Board.

In December, former board chair Kimberly Clark resigned citing a "lack of trust and mutual respect" on the board.

Shirley Thompson, a former board member, resigned a year earlier.