Wednesday, June 30, 2010

Minutes show Oyster River School Board chair did not prematurely inform town of school business

LEE — Oyster River School Board Chair Henry Brackett didn't prematurely inform town selectmen that the School Board was forming an audit committee, according to recently corrected minutes from the May 10 meeting.

Brackett's appearance at the May 10 Board of Selectmen meeting drew the ire of former School Board Chair Mark Townsend, who had multiple concerns about Brackett's appearance at the meeting.

One of his main concerns was the fact that Brackett apparently told selectmen the school board would be forming an audit committee — nine days before the board voted to do so.

The initial draft of the May 10 meeting minutes reflects just that.

"Mr. Brackett announces an Audit committee will be formed," the meeting minutes state.

However, Town Secretary Dawn Hayes submitted a correction to those meeting minutes during the June 14 selectmen meeting.

According to the correction Brackett's exact words during the May 10 meeting were, "Right now we are talking about and hopefully finalizing about an audit committee."

Town Administrator Diane Guimond said the correction was made after Brackett came into the Town Hall and asked that the minutes be reviewed.

"I think it was a result of what was going on at the School Board, he wanted the minutes to be checked for the wording," Guimond said.

Guimond said the error in the minutes was caught after staff listened to a recording of the meeting. She said it's unfortunate there was an error in the minutes, but noted the minutes are only meant to be a summary of the meeting and the public is always welcome to have the minutes double checked.

"It's the nature of the beast," she said. "We reviewed the minutes and they were amended to reflect what was said."

Brackett appearance at the May 10 meeting set off a ripple effect that culminated with an uncomfortable School Board meeting on June 2.

Townsend had other concerns about Brackett's appearance at the May 10 selectmen's meeting including Brackett discussing school board business with selectmen without the instruction of the school board and challenging board operations to selectmen.

He brought up these concerns and others about the board in a late May e-mail where he sought legal opinions about Brackett's meeting with selectmen from board attorney Matt Upton and Barrett Christina, staff attorney for the New Hampshire School Boards Association.

The request for legal advice later turned into an e-mail chain where Townsend made allegations against other board members, causing board members to take offense when the e-mails were discussed at the June 2 School Board meeting.

Townsend resigned from the board on June 7 and Brackett was elected board chair over a week later.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Improving District Central Office Communication

Today I met with Howard Colter (ORCSD Superintendent), Meredith Nadeau (ORCSD Director of Instruction), Jennifer Rief (ORCSD School Board member), and Ann Wright (ORCSD School Board member) to discuss a recent letter I sent to Howard requesting a monthly newsletter from his office (see original post discussing this letter).

The meeting became a broader discussion about District communication. I stressed that it is vital for the community at large to hear from the superintendent, such communication goes beyond individual principal's updates, PTO forums, and School Board newsletters. In particular, we talked about a two pronged approach where the superintendent provides a regular, written update (via listserv, e-mail, web site, etc.) coupled with regular, in-person, discussion groups.

The discussion groups are a vehicle to allow for face-to-face communication on topics of interest. These groups would be informal and open to the community at large. I welcome individuals to post topics of interest on this blog. I will then consolidate ideas/ suggestions and forward them onto Mr. Colter. Personally, I would like to see discussions on curricula and operational/facility improvements.

Finally, Mr. Colter reiterated to me that he is open to meeting directly with concerned parents about our District. I hope others, besides myself, take him up on his offer. In the mean time, I hope central office communications will improve and that some of my suggestions come to fruition.

Thursday, June 24, 2010

Correction of Lee Selectmen Minutes

The mischaracterization of Henry's words and false accusations of "back-room deals" is resolved as the Lee Selectmen meeting minutes are revised to reflect the actual statement made by Henry which does not state that an audit has been decided.

Correction of Lee Selectmen Minutes

MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF SELECTMEN’S MEETING JUNE 14, 2010 PAGE 2

14. Town Secretary; Dawn Hayes submits and reads a correction to the minutes of May 10, 2010 for Henry Brackett (not present). His exact words were “Right now we are talking about and hopefully finalizing about an audit committee”.

Monday, June 21, 2010

SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER VACANCY

NOTICE Oyster River Cooperative School District SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER VACANCY June 10, 2010

The Oyster River Cooperative School District School Board is seeking a citizen from Madbury to fill the vacancy on the School Board until the next election on March 8, 2011.

Citizens are encouraged to submit a brief letter of interest and summary of qualifications to the School Board no later than Thursday, June 24, 2010.

Letters may be sent via email to wdifruscio@orcsd.org or delivered to SAU #5, 36 Coe Drive, Durham, NH 03824, Attn: Wendy DiFruscio. Our office is open from 7:30 am to 4:00 pm daily.

The School Board will review letters of interest and hold brief interviews at a special School Board meeting on Wednesday, June 30, 2010 @ 7:00 pm and select one citizen to fill the vacancy.

Citizens that submit a letter of interest will receive an invitation to meet the Board on the evening of June 30, 2010.
If you have any questions, please contact Wendy DiFruscio at 868-5100, ext 20, or email at wdifruscio@orcsd.org.

Business Administrator Vacancy Announcement

Business Administrator
SAU #05 - Durham

Oyster River Cooperative School District, Durham, NH
Salary TBD commensurate with experience (Permanent) + Full benefits package offered. *PLEASE DO NOT APPLY ELECTRONICALLY* Please mail: cover letter, resume, 3 letters of recommendation, and copies of cert and transcripts to:

ORCSD, 36 Coe Dr, Durham, NH 03824

Candidates must hold a NH cert as a B.A. or be eligible for a B.A. cert, must have a strong background and experience in Business Administration, school finance and operations.

job ref.#: SAU #5
tel: 868-5100 X18
fax: 603-868-6668

Deadline July 9, 2010



June 2010 Board Newsletter

School Board Goals for 2010-2011

At this time of year, the School Board begins its discussion on a wide range of topics to be considered as School Board goals for the 2010-2011 year. These past few months of discussion have included a variety of topics and each year the board works towards determining those goals with the highest priority, a measurable outcome and have the support of a majority on the Board. This year several themes immediately percolated to the top and a board sub-committee was charged with articulating these goals for final board discussion. The sub-committee has also been drafting action items to be included under each topic. It is important to note that the list included below has not been formally adopted by the board at this point in time. The board anticipates finalizing board goals by the end of June.

1. Advance the District’s Mission Statement of “Working Together to Engage Every Learner”

2. Review and Adopt the Strategic Plan
3. Engender a Culture of Trust, Respect and Support
4. Streamline Board Operations
5. Maintain a Course of Fiscal Discipline
6. Enhance Communications

ORCSD Strategic Plan Update June 2010

The Strategic Oversight Planning Committee will be continuing its work throughout the summer and into the fall. Thanks to the work of many volunteers including staff representing each school and community members from all three towns, the committee has compiled an impressive amount of research regarding our district and educational trends.

The three working groups (including Operations, Student Achievement and Community) have completed their work and have presented their findings to the Oversight Committee. Three rounds of surveys have also been conducted including a staff survey, a student survey and most recently, a community survey. These findings will be used in the analysis phase of the strategic planning process this fall. The committee has decided to enlist the help of an experienced K-12 strategic planning facilitator in analyzing this data. The result of this analysis phase will be a list of potential strategic areas of focus.

Following the development of strategic areas of focus, the committee will hold a series of engagement evenings for staff, students and community this fall to review these findings and provide feedback. Based on this feedback, a final strategic plan will be developed and presented to the School Board for approval by January 2011. As always, if you are interested in providing feedback to the Oversight Committee, please contact us at stratplan@orcsd.org

Updates will be available on the Strategic Planning Website at: http://orcsdstrategicplan.wetpaint.com/

Thank you to all the volunteers who have generously contributed their time and energy to this exciting process.

Jocelyn O’Quinn, co-chair, Strategic Planning Oversight Committee Paula Roy, co-chair, Strategic Planning Oversight Committee

Respectfully Submitted: The Oyster River Cooperative School Board

School Board Newsletter Link:

Rochester's New Finance Director from ORCSD

ROCHESTER — The city has reached into the talent pool of the Oyster River Cooperative School District to find a replacement for former finance director Brian LeBrun.

City Manager John Scruton recently announced the hiring of Blaine Cox, a Lee resident and the business administrator for the Oyster River school district in Durham. Cox has served in that position since 2001.

The hiring comes after the April resignation of LeBrun, who accepted the position of finance director in Concord. LeBrun's absence has made for a sometimes challenging budget season for Rochester officials this year, and Scruton said he wishes Cox had come along sooner in the interview process.

"If I could have hired him in April, I would have," he said. "It takes time when you're hiring senior management."

There were 59 applicants for the position, including some from as far away as California and Florida, Scruton said. Cox's application came in as part of a third round of interviews, and the hiring committee team Scruton assembled unanimously supported Cox's hiring, Scruton said.

That committee's membership fluctuated over time, but those involved in reviewing resumes included Scruton, auditor Bob Vachon, LeBrun, interim finance director Roland Connors, Finance office assistant Shirley McCrillis, Planning Director Kenn Ortmann, Economic Development Manager Karen Pollard, Mayor T.J. Jean, Human Resources manager Diane Hoyt and Police Chief David Dubois. Scruton said he wanted a variety of perspectives.

"I felt they had good managerial experience," he said.

Scruton came away from an interview with Cox impressed with his "energy and vitality" and his understanding of finance. He said Cox's resume showed a long tenure in a responsible finance position and came with excellent references.

"I'm enthusiastic we found such a quality candidate," he said. 

As Oyster River business administrator, Cox managed a $23 million renovation and addition at Oyster River High School, worked as part of the district's leadership team on budget and policy development, served as lead administrator on the negotiations team for four collective bargaining agreements and was responsible for coordinating annual town meeting warrants, legal postings and ballot preparations.

Before he joined the school district, Cox was the town administrator in Epping from 1998 until 2001. Before that, he was properties manager for the University of New Hampshire. Cox graduated from the school with a Bachelor's degree in political science in 1984 and with a master's in public administration in 1998.

He is also a part-time adjunct professor of the university's Education Department, teaching finance and business management. He serves on the board of directors for the New Hampshire Local Government Center.

"It is with mixed emotions that I leave Oyster River as I will miss the tremendous people who work in the district here," Cox said in a statement issued by the city manager. "However, I look forward to working for such a great city as Rochester, N.H. I am confident that my skills and experiences will serve the city well and I look forward to making whatever contribution I can to the success of Rochester's future."

Scruton said Cox will join the city on July 19. 

Saturday, June 19, 2010

Diner owner denies e-mail claims from former OR chair

LEE — The owner of Gauthier's 125 Restaurant disputes one of the claim's made by the former Oyster River School Board chair in a controversial e-mail chain released earlier this week.

In the e-mail chain former Board Chair Mark Townsend alleged he was eating breakfast with Henry Brackett when the owner of the restaurant confronted Brackett about him talking School Board business at her restaurant.

"The owner came to the table just as I received coffee and informed Henry Brackett that he needed to stop discussing school board business in her diner (we hadn't begun to talk yet.) She informed Henry that customers were complaining about the impropriety of it and warned Henry that people were also purposely sitting close so they could learn of school district issues."

Restaurant Owner Misty Gauthier said that while Brackett has been to her restaurant before, neither she nor anyone on her staff has ever confronted him about talking about School Board issues at the restaurant.

She said Brackett has discussed School Board business with others at the restaurant and there have been occasions where customers have moved away from him because they didn't want to hear about it.

"In my experience, they've never been obnoxious," she said.

She said there have also been occasions where customers have approached Brackett to discuss School Board issues.

Brackett hasn't been in the restaurant recently, Gauthier said.

Townsend's e-mail chain was a result of him seeking a legal opinion about Brackett's actions at a Lee Board of Selectmen's meeting in May where Brackett, as private citizen, spoke about School Board issues and gave opinions.

Townsend said Brackett did this without board authorization.

Barrett Christina, staff attorney for the New Hampshire School Boards Association, told Townsend via e-mail that while it appears Brackett may have violated School Board policy, there wasn't enough information to determine if any laws were broken.

He told the board to seek common ground on whatever issues they have.

Townsend resigned from the board on June 7.

Friday, June 18, 2010

Breaking News: ORCSD Business Administrator Resigns?

Hello,

There was an anonymous post on the blog this morning saying Blaine Cox resigned.  I responded saying don't spread rumors like that.  This anonymous posted replied saying the position was posted.  I went and checked and sure enough there is an opening for a Business Administrator at ORCSD.

I don't know why Mr. Cox resigned.  Whatever the reason, I wish to thank him for his service and wish him well in his new endeavors whatever they may be.  While Mr. Cox and I didn't see eye to eye on a couple of issues, I attended the budget community workshops and admired his willingness to answer questions for people such as myself.  I also worked with him briefly on the strategic plan working groups and he was very willing to get the information requested from the groups.  Finally, it was no small feat to bring in the budget at less than 2% last year and he should be thanked for guiding us through that time period.

Good luck, Blaine!

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Fosters: Oyster River school board e-mails released: Missives allege improprieties among panelists

Link: PDF file of e-mail chain
DURHAM — A unanimous vote by the Oyster River School Board to waive attorney/client privilege brought about the release of a controversial e-mail chain involving the former chair of the School Board.

The e-mails were released Wednesday following a special board meeting Tuesday night. The special meeting followed a legal consultation between the board and its attorney, Matt Upton.

While the e-mail chain starts with former School Board Chair Mark Townsend seeking a legal opinion about the actions of Board Co-chair Henry Brackett at a May 10 Lee Board of Selectmen's meeting, it later turns into a list of other allegations and comments about the board.

The e-mail chain started in late May when Townsend sent e-mails to Upton and Barrett Christina, staff attorney for the New Hampshire School Boards Association.

According to a May 27 e-mail to Upton, Townsend had four concerns about Brackett's actions which include, Brackett discussing school board business with selectmen without the instruction of the school board and Brackett telling selectmen the school board would be forming an audit committee — nine days before the board voted to do so.

Townsend was also concerned about Brackett challenging board operations to selectmen. According to the minutes of that selectmen's meeting, Brackett spoke as a private citizen and not a member of the School Board.

Townsend also alleges that Brackett provided instruction to other School Board members to conduct discussions of items on the agenda prior to the legal board meetings.

In a May 27 e-mail to Christina, Townsend lays out more allegations against Brackett and other members of the board. 

"I would also add that Henry asked to meet just after we were elected Chair and Vice Chair (respectively). We had breakfast at the Route 125 Diner in Lee, NH," Townsend's e-mail reads. "The owner came to the table just as I received coffee and informed Henry Brackett that he needed to stop discussing school board business in her diner (we hadn't begun to talk yet.) She informed Henry that customers were complaining about the impropriety of it and warned Henry that people were also purposely sitting close so they could learn of school district issues."

Neither Brackett nor the owners of Gauthier's 125 Restaurant could be reached for comment on Wednesday.

Townsend goes on to allege in the e-mail to Christina that Brackett and Board Members Jocelyn O'Quinn, Ann Wright and Krista Butts worked together to push a discussion on forming an audit committee during the May 5 meeting, when such an item wasn't on the agenda.

He said the four "derailed" that meeting with a fast motion and second to put the discussion on the agenda.

"It seemed to me and (Board Members) JoAnn (Portalupi) and Jennifer (Rief) that this was a prior discussion amongst a potential quorum of the board that was not in compliance with NH RSA," Townsend wrote in the e-mail. "I will note that Mrs. Wright's husband — Tom Louriero — is a corporate attorney (chief legal officer) of the company in which I am employed. Ann is good at researching a topic that interests her, but lacks experience on a board and does not seek to understand the basics of how a board works."

Wright took exception to Townsend's comment in the e-mail and brought it up during the June 2 board meeting, where she demanded an apology. 

Townsend resigned from his post a week later, but said the decision wasn't because of the e-mails.

Townsend told Foster's on Wednesday the only reason he sought a legal opinion is because these issues with Brackett and other board members were recurring. Without giving specific examples, he said there have been multiple times when certain members of the board would talk about an issue and then contact him to either put it on the agenda or call a special meeting about the issue.

Townsend said it isn't against the law for two board members to have a conversation but it becomes a problem when those conversations become consecutive with other board members and an agreement is made with a quorum of the board. 

"This isn't a one time pattern with the board — it's a repetitive pattern," he said. "Just because you have the right to do, doesn't mean that ethically you should."

It's unknown what Upton's legal opinion about Townsend's concerns was. The board only waived attorney/client privilege in relation to Townsend's correspondence with Christina. In addition, Upton said he didn't have any e-mail correspondence with Townsend and only spoke with him by phone.

Christina told Townsend via e-mail that it appears Brackett may have violated school board policies but there wasn't enough information to determine if any laws were broken.

Christina indicated in the e-mail that Upton gave a similar opinion.

"Whatever remaining conflicts or disagreements the board has, I again urge the board to seek some common ground as to how it will communicate and operate going forward."

The School Board released the following statement after the e-mails were released.

"In releasing these communication it is our shared commitment to move forward in the spirit of openness, cooperation, and respect."